Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Debunking some myths about Harry Benjamin

Whomever bothers to read my silly blog knows I have a special place for Harry Benjamin in my heart so I feel I need to debunk some of the myths surrounding Harry and many of the issues perceived as negative for an era thankfully long since gone.

It would be easier if everyone just sat down and took the time to actually read The Transsexual Phenomenon but when people have agendas why bother with the facts.

  1. Harry Benjamin did not understand or treat the FTM transsexual. In point of fact he was the first person in the US to actually give a damn about them and in the book he mentions he had 13 FTM patients. He prescribed testosterone and cared for them like he cared for everyone else with a warm understanding heart.
  2. Harry Benjamin dealt primarily with young effeminate or feminine transsexuals and did not understand the late transitioner. Read his book. The majority of the 152 MTF transsexuals he treated were late transitioners. He didn't care if you were 14 or 55.
  3. Benjamin did not understand or support MTF transsexuals that were attracted to women or lesbian. Read the book carefully. He fully understood the differences between gender identity and sexual preference. He was as at ease with me and my boyfriends as he was with my friend and her girlfriends. He just wanted to see us happy.
  4. The transsexual had to pass for Harry to recommend surgery. Read the book.He had many heartbreaking cases and he mentions several. It was the surgeons and the hospitals that were the issue.
  5. Harry thought our problems were psychological. Read the book.  Harry was an Endocrinologist and believed something happened in the endocrine system like maybe a hormone wash. In several places he thought it might even be sort of an intersex condition. He debunked people like John Money and I know because I was on a TV show with both of them. He knew Freud and even Freud believed this is not a mental illness.
  6. The Standards of Care were Harry's idea. Harry believed everyone was different and the process for everyone by definition was different. Harry preferred one to be on hormones before contemplating transition but Real Life Experience was not a requirement based on a specific time frame. I knew a girl that because of work had to be boy for money and girl for life and she had surgery and had a good life and ironically from my same home town.  What was in the water??
  7. Harry only treated transsexuals. Harry treated everyone that fit into his Gender Disorientation Scale from transvestites to Type VI transsexuals. He cared about us all and did feel there was some connection between transvestism and transsexualism.  That might tick off the transsexual only crowd and probably explains some of their dislike for him but he cared for us all. If you read his book he explains he had an inkling but no proof transvestism was a very mild form of transsexualism and I know of several transvestites that had "The Letter" in case it might help.
  8. Harry considered kids like me homosexual transsexuals. Read the book.  To the contrary he considered us heterosexual girls. If the mind says girl then boys are the heterosexual sex target unless the MTF transsexual was lesbian which fit a small percentage of early transitioners although it must be noted Harry dealt with very few kids as young as me and several of my friends. We were atypical of those that sought his help.
  9. Harry would have been upset with transsexuals being under the umbrella term transgender. Read the book. Harry believed in inclusion not exclusion and recognized there were very distinct differences but what was the GLB to do? They needed an inclusive term and at times I get irked being categorized under it but that is usually because of personal reasons.
  10. Harry would support The Harry Benjamin Syndrome crowd. I must admit I agree with the intersex premise but after spending a short time on the site I think Harry would scream "take my name off" because too many are homophobic and if there is an elitist group it is them. It is ironic because I know and really like Charlotte and it has gotten away from her original intention of promoting transsexualism as intersex. I could go on for two months about some of the nice people and the far too many loons I met there.
  11. Harry wanted you to be Stealth.  Harry wanted what was best for you. Harry knew some would never be able to easily pass and it was out of the question. I was a child or girl of the 50's.  I wanted a husband, a family, a baby, a home with a white picket fence and all the programmed nonsense we were fed in those days.  Harry thought I should have gone back to school and gotten my Doctorate and taught.

I don't have all the answers but I do have several boxes full of letters between Harry and my mother including my mom's copies of her letters to him and the majority were written in German to avoid her mother realizing what they were which is another story. Mom was a noted linguist and thought German was safe but was amused Harry called her Marta rather than Martha. My mother was an inquisitive woman and asked a lot of interesting questions and Harry answered every one of them.

If anyone has any misconceptions or questions about him i would be glad to answer the question if I know the answer.

OMG there is no what!!!!

When I left my government position after 3+ years to completely transition in New York City my Uncle Al offered me a job as the on-site Engineer representing his company during construction of a 60+ story office building in midtown Manhattan.  I was to manage  the installation of all the Mechanical Systems, piping, ducting, fire safety equipment, and wiring needed to provide services such as HVAC, electrical, and plumbing for a high rise building.

Al is a wonderful caring man and one of the few in the family that always supported me. I had undergrad and graduate degrees in Astronautical Engineering and Astrophysics so I was kind of hesitant but he was adamant I could handle the job. I had been to his Headquarters in downtown Boston many times as the androgynous me.  He was my dads younger brother and we were close so he knew me and most people there knew me primarily because Al talked a lot about the project in Houston.

He said if I could do the work I had done this side of Mechanical Engineering would be easy. I went a little crazy buying new outfits at Jordan Marsh, Filenes, and other good stores and I was ready and just stopped being androgynous. I spent about 3 weeks in the Boston office getting up to speed and it was helped by the fact I had spent a summer working there while in college. I was ready and off to New York I went.

I arrived at the job site on a Monday in early September truly unaware of what I was getting myself into. I have no fear of heights and had flown a lot in Texas out of necessity and out of kindness which is another story but I was in for a shock. The building was just a shell with about 25 stories of steel frame up and OMG there were no freaking walls. No big deal I was not afraid of much right about then but I was in for another shock.

I was 23 and there had never ever been an on-site female Engineer for any construction of any high rise ever in NYC and certainly not one like me. I was under the impression it was just a get to know you meeting with the Engineers who would work for me. I had no idea about men with female bosses, and the Engineers supervising the construction of the building itself. I could feel both the tension and the apprehension in our trailer office. There were a lot of people working there and I was a 23 year old twerp with no experience and I didn't dress well for the meeting. My mini skirt and heels were not correct work attire and I learned quickly I would be tested.

If you go into most high rise buildings you will notice many do not have a 13th floor that is occupied because of superstition and the fact the basement, sub-basement, 13th floor if used, and the roof contain most of the major mechanical systems for the building. This building had building management and systems on 13 so they asked me to go up to see the layout. They were of course testing me.

I had an excuse since heels wouldn't work but a guy produced a pair of new work boots and said these are from your Uncle and I knew he knew I was to be tested. Not very elegant but on they went and off to the elevator we went. Well elevator is a misnomer here. Attached to the side of the steel frame was a cage and what was used to move it up and down and I had a heart attack. All it had was a gate on the entrance side and wire mesh for walls.

I got in and pressed against the back wall for safety because I was scared to death. I was shaking like a leaf in a nor'easter. One of the high steel workers jumped into the elevator before we moved and saw the suits with me and noticed the terror in my eyes and pushed them aside and took both my hands which were clammy and shaking and told me to hold on everything will be OK.

As we start up about 5 guys run under the elevator hoping to get a look because the floor was wire mesh but I was so frightened I had my legs squeezed together to keep from wetting myself. OMG the thing shook and rattled and bucked and bent as we flew up the side of the building. A parachute seemed a sensible purchase at that moment.


We get to 13 and when I got out OMG there was no freaking floor except for a trackway covered with steel mesh and it felt like there was a forty knot wind whistling through the steel girders and balance was an issue. My second thought was these steel workers are freaking crazy.  I look up and guys are staring down at me waving, smiling, giving my new friend the thumbs up so my new friend decides to stay out of pity I am sure and puts his arm around my waist and walks me around and I heard not a single word anyone said to me I was so petrified.

The steel worker stayed with me the entire time and took me down in the elevator and I was ashen white and had hardly said a word the entire time. He escorts me into the trailer that is our on-site office and I manage to squeak out a 'thank you' as I fell into a chair in relief and he proceeds to tell me I did great.  It seems those assholes, his words, do this to every newbie that comes on site and most will not go up.  In fact he said they were supposed to give me a safety indoctrination before I was even allowed in the steel shell because it is the most dangerous place in construction because rivets, hammers, and all kinds of stuff are always falling and you can get killed or maimed.

Now this may have been to make me feel better but it didn't. After a few queasy minutes he is still there and I asked him where I could buy appropriate work clothes because mini-skirt was not it. Around this time I realize he is seriously cute which should tell you how scared I am because I never miss cute guys. We agree he will take me at lunch time to a store and I will get work cloths.To get an idea how scared I was he is standing there and I suddenly realized I was up there for 90 minutes and it is lunch time now.

The people who were to work for me came back to the trailer with smug smirks and I tell the senior person under me if I ever hear of him taking another person up the building before they have had a safety briefing he is fired. He turns ashen white and as I leave with my new friend to buy appropriate work cloths I turned to the man I had threatened and just said "gotcha" and smiled. I never ever had trouble with him or anyone else again.

So the moral of the story is here I am working in the fashion capital of the country dreaming of my new life of glamor in New York City and I get to travel to work almost every day in work boots, work jeans, a work shirt, and a hardhat dressing more boy than I have in my life.  Sometimes a girl just cannot win.






Tuesday, October 5, 2010

A weird flight to NYC and I meet another transsexual for first time

In late March of 1960 my mom had to go with me for my first visit to Harry's office in NYC. I wasn't happy going as a sort of boy because I had met Harry the first time as a girl but it was a necessity because of what happened in February. Harry had actually flown to Boston to visit me in the hospital because he was worried but we never really had the talk he wanted because of the circumstances.

I think we were on the Eastern Shuttle to LaGaurdia but it was a weird flight. I was shy and timid in most circumstances and physcially didn't project boy well or as my older brother Ray said "not at all". It was not because I was flamboyant I just was not facially and physically at 14 very masculine. If I tried really hard I could do it but it was a lot of effort I was unwilling to make at this point in my life.

As was the norm I catch people staring at me while we wait for the plane to load and it gets me nervous because it often leads to trouble. Mom pats my hand and tells me to relax it will be OK. We board and about 15 minutes into the flight I hear this over the drone of the propellers.

Elderly woman: 'Can you believe that pretty girl wearing those mannish cloths?  She has to be a lesbian'.

A lesbian? I knew what a lesbian was and I stand up looking to see her.

Me: 'Mom where is the lesbian?'

Mom: 'Sweetie that would be you'.

Me: Mom I'm not a lesbian I'm a transsexual'.

Mom: 'I know dear but you do look kind of like a lesbian dressed that way'.

Me: 'Mom, you told me to wear this.'

All the time we are talking people start staring so I guess I educated people on Eastern Airlines. I wasn't a lesbian because I was a transsexual.  Now since I had not known I was a transsexual and had never heard the  word transsexual until 3 months before I am sure those people on the plane were scratching their head. There were lots of stares as we left the plane for sure.

Mom gets a Cab and we give him the address and as we are driving the cab driver is continually staring at me in his rear view mirror. Every time I catch him he looks away. I catch him staring at me again and I tell him the following.

Me:'I'm not a lesbian. I'm a transsexual.'

The poor driver almost drives off the road and he didn't stare once more. Mom slapped my hand and told me not to be sassy or something like that but he didn't stare. I could be a precocious little brat sometimes.

When we get to Harry's office I am met gleefully by this wonderful woman who runs the office and I sit beside this absolutely stunning woman who smiles at me like she knows something I don't. I am escorted into see Harry and he looks at me.

Harry: 'You don't do boy well at all'.

Me: 'Yeah I know.  Everyone on the plane thought I was a lesbian and so did our cab driver'.

Harry(Big smile):  'There is nothing wrong with being a lesbian'.

Me: 'I know that but I need to be a girl first and besides I like boys as you already know'.


We talk for a while and I get a physical exam and he says he can notice the changes already from the low dosage of estrogen. Harry asks how many of which pills I am taking and hey I am a kid and if one was good 4 or 5 was better and I get a good talking to about sticking with the schedule so the process isn't too fast because I am still in high school and they are not going to be happy if things changed too quickly. It was not likely things could get any more weird than they already were. Breast development and boys gym should have come to mind immediately.

We agree on the dosage and he calls mom in to make sure she distributes my hormones and mom knows I knew the correct dosage but doesn't squeal on me. She did in her next letter to Harry but that doesn't count. Harry then asks me if I would like to meet another transsexual who has actually gone through the entire process and has had her operation. I am excited because I have never met another transsexual just like I have never met a lesbian. I really did want to meet a lesbian because that would have been fun and interesting.

We are escorted into another room and sitting there is the beautiful woman I sat next to in the waiting room and she hardly gets a word out before I am bombarding her with questions about everything. Like I said a precocious little brat at times. Harry gets me calmed down and mom and I sit down for 45 minutes with this woman who was in the city for just a day and was doing Harry a favor and meeting with a kid Harry wanted her to talk with.

She was wonderful and nice and such a total lady unlike the brat questioning her.She was gracious, complimentary, so kind, and answered a lot of questions and some were detailed. Her name was Christine Jorgensen and the worst part about it was I had no idea who she was.  Not a clue.

As we were getting ready to leave she takes me aside and tells me I will be a beautiful young lady and while she is saying that I am thinking if I look half as beautiful as her I will be very happy. She was 33 at the time and photos do not do her justice.  If I had known I would have thanked her from the bottom of my heart for her amazing courage.  There are times not knowing is good but this was not one of them.

My mom exchanged notes with her for 20 years because she wanted to know how I was doing. Quite an amazing lady. My mom was kind of amazing also.


Monday, October 4, 2010

To Whom it may concern or The Letter.

Working and living in NYC in the late 60's as a young transsexual was interesting. If you were read and someone screamed "OMG it is a Tranny" (couldn't resist that Elizabeth) one of many possible outcomes occurred.

1. If a cop was around they could arrest you for "impersonating" and that meant the male holding cell at the local precinct.  Not a very good outcome.

2. If no cop was around one could get get out of the area and avoid the issue.

3. If a cop was arresting you "The Letter" might help. If the cop had a heart "The Letter" might result in him just telling you to move on.

What was "The letter"? If you were one of Harry's girls, as we called ourselves, Harry provided us with a letter that hopefully would engender some sympathy and avoid one ending up in the slammer. We were to carry it with us at all times upon penalty of Harry getting upset if we got bagged and didn't at least give it a try.

Below is what one of my letter said. It seemed to change every time I managed to lose it. Thankfully I never had to use it.

The last line is funny because Harry knew my penchant for dating musicians and being drawn to bad boys. They were exciting, sexy, and fun and didn't care we were transsexual. Everyone I dated knew about me and musicians seemed quite understanding and particularly the British ones. A lot of them dated transsexuals or had affairs with one. I know of many really famous musicians that had no issues dating one of us. I'm not sure this could or would happen today.

*****************************************************************************
Harry Benjamin M. D.
44 East 67th Street
New York, NY 19921
(212) 427 427-4455

To Whom it May Concern:

This is to certify that the bearer, ____ ____, is under my professional care and observation. This patient belongs to the rather rare group of transsexuals, also referred to in the medical literature as psychic hermaphrodites. Their anatomical sex, that is to say, the body, is male. Their psychological sex, that is to say, the mind, is female.

Therefore they feel as women, and if they live and dress as such, they do so out of an irrepressible inner urge, and not to commit a crime, to "masquerade," or to "impersonate" illegally.It is my considered opinion, based on many years' experience, that transsexuals are mostly introverted and nonaggressive and therefore no threat to society. In their feminine role they can live happier lives and they are usually less neurotic than if they were forced to live as men. I do not think that society is endangered when it assumes a permissive attitude, and grants these people the right to their particular pursuit of happiness.Like all patients of this type, ____ ____ has been strictly advised to behave well and inconspicuously at all times and to be careful in choosing friends.

Dr. Harry Benjamin
Signature

*****************************************************************************

Sunday, October 3, 2010

Comment Policy

I have no policy. I will never moderate comments or attempt to disable any access to commenting. I am not adverse to putting my foot in my mouth because I learned as an Engineer that information and facts often get blurred so if I am wrong I want to know about it. Hopefully I do not offend some but if I do just tell me in a comment. I will happily publish an apology if wrong.

Liz

Ready for Induction

Just to offset the serious post a little piece of the funny side of T life during the Vietnam war.


I never registered for Selective Service but my grandmother made sure I was on the draft rolls somehow. Between college at a young age, then grad school, and finally work in Houston for the US Government I was always exempt from the draft for Vietnam. I am not sure what the status was but it wasn’t 4F but probably exempt.  I should have just gone to the draft board and they would have taken one look and I would have been 4F.

Don’t ask don’t tell was not a policy in my day,  It was simply don't bother but they had no clue about transsexuals so if I showed up they wouldn’t have asked and I wouldn’t have had to tell because by 17 the most difficult thing in my life was boy unless I gave it maximum effort. Many times I had been accused by fly-boys in Houston of being a girl pretending to be a boy so I could work there. They recruited me knowing what I was but I confused more than a few.When I left Houston after 3+ years my government employer reported to Selective Service that I was now eligible for the draft in August of 1969.I had the money now and I needed to complete the long trip towards the real me I had started in my early teens.

I could not change paperwork without surgery in those days but my Uncle’s Company, I worked for him in NYC, gave me a  Corporate Credit Card in my new name and I managed to open a checking account using Elizabeth and at the same time Selective Service began the search for me. In general I was a happy little girl in NYC and mom would send me a mail package from home once in a while and I would just throw out the draft stuff. A girl doesn’t need to worry about the draft.

1969 turned into 1970 and Selective Service began threatening me through my mother by telling her they would arrest me and do all kinds of nasty things to me.  I would have been very popular in a military prison although I might not have enjoyed the popularity. My surgery was completed in January of 1971 and two Military Police appeared at my old home looking for me. Mom tried to explain to them I was now a girl but that excuse was not working with Military Intelligence despite reams of documentation.

It turned out that they probably wanted my Engineering expertise for the war machine and I was never in danger of seeing action and besides olive green is not my best color. They were in reality not ever going to find me because now the name change was in effect, my social security was  about to reference that change along with the necessary letters from Harry and the Surgeon verifying me as female and I didn't look much like a boy. I filed my taxes through my old name at my original home which was smart but brought them to mom.

My mom called me in a panic one day and told me they would issue an arrest warrant for me unless I showed up for induction on a specific date which coincided exactly with my meeting with Social Security. I actually had induction paperwork in my hand and my mom wanted the harassment stopped she felt was not her responsibility so I decided to report. Mom was an anchor but not someone I wanted mad at me.

I flew to Boston and I had a very pleasant meeting with Social Security and went to my mom’s house and changed for my induction. I decided to wear the Adolpho outfit my dear friend Oscar had given me which was a mauve silk blouse with a plunging neckline which showed cleavage and matching mini skirt that reeked of elegance and was sexy. Matching heels and a very sexy bra visible through the top and an elegant winter coat because it was actually winter.

My mom was home and her first words were, ‘you cannot wear that to the draft board’, and I wondered aloud 'what would they do arrest me or induct me'. Oscar always liked me with my hair up so up it went and some nice jewelry finished the look along with appropriate makeup and a pair of large sunglasses.  I was going for mysterious elegance which was probably more trashy elegance but it would work. A girl should try and look good when facing induction into military service.

I am not going to try and tell you I wasn’t nervous because I was. I have never been comfortable when people know what I once was and after my entrance and my offer to be inducted I would be noticed. My driver’s license was from Texas and needed to be changed so even driving over to Selective Service was a possible issue if stopped.

It was very warm when I entered the building so I took my coat off and made my way to the Selective Service Induction Center and calmed myself and walked in. It was noisy with a table on the back wall and groups of young men on the right with shirts off that were getting just a cursory physical and when the click, click, click of my heels was heard every face seemed to turn in unison as I took off my sun glasses to see where I had to go.

I distinctly remember thinking those poor boys could end up fighting this senseless war and dying and I felt sad but I was jolted back to reality by whistles and some remarks from both the inductees, the inducted, and the military guys. It went something like this.

‘What the fuck is she doing here?’

‘Fuck, I want her in my platoon.’

‘Now that ass is worth fighting for.’

‘Shit, you can see her tits.’

Under certain circumstances a girl might be flattered by said comments and I probably was a little. There were four lines of boys waiting processing and I went to the end of my letter appropriate line and stood.

Guy with stripes: ‘Hey honey what are you doing in line?’

Me: ‘I came to be inducted as ordered.’

Guy with stripes: ‘Step up front honey and you morons step aside and let this pretty young thing talk with me.’

Second guy with stripes: ‘OK sweetie what is this about again?’

Me: ‘Here are my induction orders. I was drafted.’

Third guy with more stripes: ‘These are for <insert my old name> and that isn’t you sweet thing.’

Me: ‘Well that was once me.’

You could have heard a gnat fart at 200 yards after that comment.

Another guy with no stripes who seemed important: ‘This is another fucking joke by that fucking asshole in Boston. He gets this girl to come in here and fuck with us after our prank last week.’

I am now a little lost myself. What prank was he talking about?

Me (pissed I have to do this): ‘Sir, that was my name and was me.’

They will not believe me and everyone is laughing because they all think it is a joke.

First guy with stripes. ‘Charley put you up to this didn’t he?’

Me (very nervous): ‘No sir. I was once a boy.  Not much of one but I was one.’

Third guy with lots of stripes. ‘There is no way that is true honey. Who put you up to this? Are you one of the hookers Charley is kidding me about?’

I finally gain a little composure because I have never ever tried to convince someone I was once a boy and wasn’t sure whether being called a hooker was complimentary.

Me (desperate to get it over): ‘Please believe me. Here is my paperwork.’

I hand them everything I have from my doctors and all the men with stripes and the important guy are shuffling papers between each other and looking at me and muttering to themselves in disbelief and it is again Library quiet and I hear the murmurings.

Second guy with stripes: ‘I never saw anything like this in Waco!!’

Third guy with all the stripes: ‘Give her I mean him a 4F.’

Me (defiant):  ‘I am a girl. I am not a him.’

That upset me and they hand me all my paperwork.

Guy who seemed important: ‘You can leave now.’

Me:  ‘Thank you.’

Guy with lots of stripes: ‘Fuck me.’

Me (very defiant): ‘Sorry you are not my type.’

As I turn to walk out I replaced the sunglasses because I was nearly in tears and nervous and there were murmurings in the inductees.

‘No way that is a guy.’

‘Used to be a guy you dumb fuck.’

‘No freaking way that is not a girl.’

‘Holy shit.’

Then from near the front of the building this one rugged looking guy stares at me as he pulls his shirt on and yells.

‘Fuck that. I’d do her right here and now cause she is fine.’

Some other guy yells.

‘Give him a 4F.’

As I was walking out I here a few more I’d do her comments I am sure hoping they could get a 4F.

I was shaking so bad I had to sit on a nearby bench outside the door to calm down and then I needed the ladies room.  I’m thinking I should have had my mom drive me because I was parallel parked and there was no way I could get out of the space in this condition.

As I exit the Ladies Room I crash into the rugged guy and he has to hold me to keep me from falling to the floor. It was like running into a wall.

Rugged Guy: ‘Sorry. You OK? Damn, you smell good!’

Me (trying to be cool because he was really cute): ‘ I’m Liz. Nice try with the comment.  Looking for a 4F?’

Rugged Guy: ‘I’m Brian.  Hey I meant it you look amazing and if it got me 4F that would have been nice also.’

We are still very close together and I see two of the guys with stripes exiting the induction office.

Me (whisper): ‘This might help.’

I kissed him gently on the lips. He never flinched.

Me (whisper): ‘Look behind you. It is up to you now.’

The rugged kid glances and grabs me and gives me a really passionate kiss which in all honesty took my breath away.

Guy with lots of stripes: ‘Boy you get your fucking ass back in this office! Right now soldier!!’

He winks at me and before he heads back in I scribble my phone number in NYC on a piece of paper and hand it to him.

Me (loudly): ‘Please call if you ever get to NYC.  I promise I’ll show you a really good time.’

Guy with all the stripes: ‘Get back in that room soldier.  No fag is getting inducted on my watch.’

I always wondered if I might have saved a life with a  kiss because they  marked me as gay on my papers so in their minds it was a guy kissing a guy. He never did call. Too bad he was really cute.


The Person Ovesey Transsexual Study

Sorry for the serious post being first but someone just really upset me on a blog.


http://ariablue.wordpress.com/2010/09/29/last-gasps-of-the-old-order/

She has a particular point of view and is one of the politicos involved in the histrionics between those transsexuals not upset with the use of the term transgender and those totally offended by the use of transgender. She quite obviously belongs to the totally offended  side which is her right.

If you disagree with her myopic view of the world or tick her off you will be moderated and your posts will be deleted.  She is decidedly biased against anyone she perceives as elitist when in reality she is the elitist.  Ask her a hard question and be banned.  Open discussion is not part of her mantra.  She is correct and anyone who even disagrees partially is the enemy.


The Transsexual Phenomenon


The above link is to The Transsexual Phenomenon written by Dr. Harry Benjamin and was the first  true study of us. I am surprised how few have read it.  I am stunned how few actually understood it. I am staggered by how many have misinterpreted it and misquoted it or twisted what was said.

I guess I will date myself right here and now. Harry Benjamin was my doctor and my friend. He saved my life and in 1970 -71 asked me to talk to a Dr. Ethel Person as part of a study and I agreed although I am inherently distrustful of shrinks but I found her pleasant and quite nice and we became friendly.

When the study was published I was stunned to be honest. I was part of the study and I knew two others who were part of it and friends of mine. We never talked about anything mentioned in the study directly. We talked about our lives as children until the current time and at the time I was 24 and had close to enough money for surgery. In point of fact Harry might have been more upset by the study than anyone.

http://www.avitale.com/PrimarySecondary.htm

Person-Ovesey Study Synopsis

Aria Blue uses the study to support her view of young transsexuals (children) who may or may not have been effeminate and I believe her misguided belief that she is this type of primary transsexual Person-Ovesey portrayed which is neither homosexual nor heterosexual as a child which is a baffling concept but driven to get a sex change at all cost. I believe they had a total of 20 participants in the study.  Harry had 150+ in his book. Who understands it better? Driven at all cost does not fit many older transitioners so where does the study fit them in?

I am posting this to refute what they found because as one of the participants in the study I walked into her office and asked her where I fit in late 1974 and she said Secondary because I liked boys so I was a homosexual transsexual where by Harry's definition I was a Type VI high intensity transsexual and according to Harry the study was bogus. My avatar is exactly how I appeared to her except I was better clothed.

They based the Secondary categorization on the fact I confused a lot of people over my gender beginning by age 10. I was never flamboyant or openly feminine. At the time I did not know my T level was measured as a child and never exceeded 20 which along with genetics fit my appearance. I was exceedingly shy and withdrawn because I was bullied and Dr. Person was never informed how early I started hormones which was very early. I did have a boyfriend starting at 14 but I NEVER mentioned him to her primarily because I had no memory of him. I told her I realized at around 11-12 I was very attracted to boys despite the fact they often hurt me. I told her how I just wanted to meet a nice man and get married and have lots of sex. I wanted sex badly.

She did ask me about a picture of me taken with a noted guitar player when we exited a club in 1970 when it appeared in a local New York paper after we had begun meeting and I told her he was just a friend and it was the truth at that time. She was privy to the few pictures of me as a child and based on this and a comment from Harry that Liz, my nickname, was a very intense transsexual as a child and driven almost beyond reason to changer her sex I was defined as a homosexual transsexual.

She never asked me once if I had ever had sex with a man and we met pre and post surgery. This was intended to be a very narrow focus study and both Person and Ovesey were more interested in homosexual males and their relationship to transsexuals than in a distinct definition of or categorization of transsexuals.

Aria Blue uses the definition change for primary and secondary as an example of the transgender community blurring the "true" definition of transsexuals when it was done primarily to follow the Type V and Type VI definitions clearly defined in Harry's book. Aria Blue is not afraid to hatch the chicken before it was ever an egg to fit her view of herself and the world.

In the future she might be better to choose a more relevant and accepted study and she quite nimbly avoids the simple fact the Person-Ovesey study correlates closely to Blanchard and his fellow loons beliefs in several key areas.

Liz